Buying a 2018 REX i3s

BMW i3 Forum

Help Support BMW i3 Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Marscar

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2022
Messages
19
Hello!

First post, and I have yet to buy an i3, so my questions will be about that for now ...

I have seen a 2018 i3s REX with 57,000 on the clock, with one previous owner
The positive side of me says this is a good sign ... not low miles and multiple owners suggesting issues, garage time, and standing time.

However, having picked up a little about ev's in general I'd be interested to know if anyone on here thinks I'm being overly cautious about this particular vehicle.

It's being sold by a large-ish independent franchise that works in volume to keep their prices at the low end of the usual range for trade sales.

What I'm guessing has happened with this car is that they took it in at the end of a lease, at "x" miles near the end of July, listed it with those miles, then did the MOT which passed at "x"+4miles and it has sat for two months, showing "x"+5 miles on the clock.

I will try to post a photo of the screen, but in case that fails, I THINK it is showing:

1) the state of charge as being very low with the range left on the battery as 1 mile.

2) the fuel icon has a triangle exclamation mark warning light above it, with 1.5 of the 4 bars showing the fuel level.

I read this as the dealership having had it sat for two months, using petrol to make any small moves ... and therefore the battery has been left at the low end of it's capacity for all that time.

I thought that ev batteries should ideally be left standing for long periods at 50 to 80%.

They haven't yet answered my request for an image of the battery capacity (via the "secret menu") and I suspect they either don't really know how to do that, or are too busy to want to!

The middle ground between avoiding an earlier i3 and our budget means "120"ah batteries are out of reach, and the REX becomes a necessary factor on top of a "94"ah battery.

EDIT:
I appreciate that a 94ah battery will only show about 88ah at the start of it's ownership.
Also this car is not local, so I'm not sure I want to make a 260+ round trip only to find that the capacity has dropped too far.

Thanks for reading this far!

I look forward to boring you with posts from an actual owner before too long :D
 
Unlike many 60 Ah battery packs, 94 Ah and 120 Ah battery packs seem to degrade at much slower rates, so it's very likely that the usable battery pack capacity would be high … unless allowing it to remain at a very low charge level for a couple of months has accelerated degradation.

"Petrol", "MOT", and "miles" makes me deduce that you are in the U.K. where ambient temperatures tend to be not so hot … although that might not have been true while this i3 was sitting at a low charge level. I think that the battery cell degradation rate while at a low charge level would be greater at high and low temperatures, so you might be OK. Too bad the dealer didn't just plug in the included charging cable to charge the battery pack.
 
alohart said:
Unlike many 60 Ah battery packs, 94 Ah and 120 Ah battery packs seem to degrade at much slower rates, so it's very likely that the usable battery pack capacity would be high … unless allowing it to remain at a very low charge level for a couple of months has accelerated degradation.

"Petrol", "MOT", and "miles" makes me deduce that you are in the U.K. where ambient temperatures tend to be not so hot … although that might not have been true while this i3 was sitting at a low charge level. I think that the battery cell degradation rate while at a low charge level would be greater at high and low temperatures, so you might be OK. Too bad the dealer didn't just plug in the included charging cable to charge the battery pack.

Hi, and thank you :)
Yes, "Good old Blighty" I'm afraid :-/

It's this that I'm wondering about:

"unless allowing it to remain at a very low charge level for a couple of months has accelerated degradation".

...and the fact that we did have a pretty HOT time of it for most of that time.

They're not helping themselves as sellers so far, but then maybe they don't have to try that hard?
Thanks again!
 
..... so what would be an ok read out for battery capacity on a 94ah after nearly 60,000 miles?
Less than 88ah I guess, but by how much?!
 
The betta kappa max starts around 29.5-30, anything in the 28-29 should be ok.
 
agzand said:
The betta kappa max starts around 29.5-30, anything in the 28-29 should be ok.

Hi, and thanks for you reply ...
Those numbers are surprising.
I must have misunderstood!
I thought the Batt Kap number started at around 90% of the nominal capacity, and was into "warranty territory" if it dropped below 70% .......
Do I need to go back to school?!
EDIT:
Ah! .... A 94ah will be a 33kwh, so you're referring to the % of THAT. ... Goddit :)
 
Just been to see the car in question and the "hidden menu" gave a read out of 29.7 on a 33kwh battery after four years and 45,000 miles .... We went for it ....... :-0
 
That is amazing for that high mileage. BMW did a good job with 94ah batteries.
 
agzand said:
That is amazing for that high mileage. BMW did a good job with 94ah batteries.

Sorry, only just seen this...
I must admit I had a moment when I cynically thought that the software could have been tweaked, as in when owners take their in-warranty battery in to show a 70% or less read out (warranty cut/in?) only to have the dealer "test" it and return it with a higher % because the top end buffer has been altered.
Maybe I've been reading those threads all wrong but anyway I decided the car had too much going for it, and 29.7 was SO good that even if a tweaked figure there's plenty of life in there yet.
 
I can't find my previous posts talking about this, but my 2017's battery capacity was high like yours when I bought the car at 22,000 miles, and hadn't changed when I sold it at around 50,000 miles. So I wouldn't expect yours has had anything unusual done to it to boost the kappa max number. Congrats.
 
Hi

I have a 2018 94Ah i3S Rex - Happy to answer any real-world use questions.

My car had 28,700 miles on it when I bought it 12months ago, now has 47,000 miles.

The rear tyres have lasted iro 15k miles, and the last set of Bridgestones were £200 each :?

I Charge at home, rarely use public Chargers and only occasionally use the Rex (I am on-call for work, so occasionally do "unexpected" miles when I had planned to Charge the car at home.

Nothing has broken.

I put a set of BMW mudflaps on (though the guidance says they don' fit due to wheel-arch lips in the S, I had to make a small cut in the flap - took 2mins and means they fit)

Very, very happy with the car.
 
eNate said:
I can't find my previous posts talking about this, but my 2017's battery capacity was high like yours when I bought the car at 22,000 miles, and hadn't changed when I sold it at around 50,000 miles. So I wouldn't expect yours has had anything unusual done to it to boost the kappa max number. Congrats.

Once again, apologies for the late reply ... I need to set up my notifications properly!
An update ...
We bought the car four months ago at 42k miles, NOT 45k miles :-/
NOW we are at 45k miles and today's reading off a battery at 79% charge (so conservative?)
is "28.6".

Thought it might be worth mentioning that clearly these numbers are a bit "bendy" given that the read-out also says there is 22.1 available from the 79%.

22.1 is more like 77% of 28.6 so,
to put it another way:

79% of 28.6 is nearer 22.6.
22.1 is 79% of 27.97 (say 28)

I'm wondering is the discrepancy most likely to be in the % figure?

Anyway, using "full" capacity as 33kwh and 30kwh respectively,
28.6 represents 95% and 86% ....

Any tips on which numbers to ignore?!
 
i3SGB said:
Hi

I have a 2018 94Ah i3S Rex - Happy to answer any real-world use questions.

My car had 28,700 miles on it when I bought it 12months ago, now has 47,000 miles.

The rear tyres have lasted iro 15k miles, and the last set of Bridgestones were £200 each :?

I Charge at home, rarely use public Chargers and only occasionally use the Rex (I am on-call for work, so occasionally do "unexpected" miles when I had planned to Charge the car at home.

Nothing has broken.

I put a set of BMW mudflaps on (though the guidance says they don' fit due to wheel-arch lips in the S, I had to make a small cut in the flap - took 2mins and means they fit)

Very, very happy with the car.

Hi, good to hear of yet another happy bunny!
We've just had some warranty work done (one year on a BMW "approved used car" because we were getting judder on regen.
Sounds as if it was a suspension strut damaged (pot hole) by PO.
Rear tyres were worn unevenly (down to 0mm on external edges) so the dealership replaced those with new (Bridgestone unfortunately as only these are warranted ... can't have everything! ... which are available fitted at £160+ each)
The steering wheel now sits five degrees anti-clockwise, but given a trip to the dealership would mean one, possibly two, three hour round trips I'm going to try to get them to agree to a closer BMW dealership doing that.
 
Marscar said:
Thought it might be worth mentioning that clearly these numbers are a bit "bendy" given that the read-out also says there is 22.1 available from the 79%.

22.1 is more like 77% of 28.6 so,
to put it another way:

79% of 28.6 is nearer 22.6.
22.1 is 79% of 27.97 (say 28)

I'm wondering is the discrepancy most likely to be in the % figure?

Anyway, using "full" capacity as 33kwh and 30kwh respectively,
28.6 represents 95% and 86% ....

Any tips on which numbers to ignore?!
It's not possible to measure battery capacity or charge level directly, so these are all calculated values. The calculations depend on temperature, how fast the battery pack has been charged or discharged, how similar the charge levels of each of the 96 battery cells are, etc. I have seen the Batt. Kapa. max values vary by up to 4 kWh from measurement to measurement for the 22 kWh battery pack in our previous 2014 i3, so one shouldn't put too much faith in these values.
 
alohart said:
Marscar said:
Thought it might be worth mentioning that clearly these numbers are a bit "bendy" given that the read-out also says there is 22.1 available from the 79%.

22.1 is more like 77% of 28.6 so,
to put it another way:

79% of 28.6 is nearer 22.6.
22.1 is 79% of 27.97 (say 28)

I'm wondering is the discrepancy most likely to be in the % figure?

Anyway, using "full" capacity as 33kwh and 30kwh respectively,
28.6 represents 95% and 86% ....

Any tips on which numbers to ignore?!
It's not possible to measure battery capacity or charge level directly, so these are all calculated values. The calculations depend on temperature, how fast the battery pack has been charged or discharged, how similar the charge levels of each of the 96 battery cells are, etc. I have seen the Batt. Kapa. max values vary by up to 4 kWh from measurement to measurement for the 22 kWh battery pack in our previous 2014 i3, so one shouldn't put too much faith in these values.

Understood ... That's what I meant by "bendy" numbers.
Useful though as a small-ball-park health check when buying ... and to follow progress, if the same parameters (state of charge, time since charged, time since used, external temp) are used each time :)
 
Back
Top